I struggle from time to time with putting cousins in their proper place—in the family tree,that is.
In earlier times it was not uncommon for siblings in one family to marry siblings in another family. After all, their social world was small, confined mostly to the county,town, church and school that made up their neighborhood. Checking census reports makes it clear that many marriages united neighboring farms. So when I was puzzling over just how the Anderson family is related to the Bird family, I decided to check out the relationships between them, and two other families as well.
The Birds
My curiosity about the Birds started with my half-aunt, Rhema Fair talking about how my grandfather Leonard Guy Anderson’s aunts and uncles disliked his second wife, my grandmother, Vera Stout. Why were they convinced Vera had stolen Guy away from his first wife, Lilis Bird, causing Lilis to die of a broken heart?
Why were Guy Anderson’s relatives so protective of Lilis Bird Anderson? It turns out Guy was not the first to marry a Bird but none had married a Stout. (The Stout family came from another county, a day’s journey away) The Birds were merely protecting family.
Then I looked at the connections between Andersons and Birds. A plat map of the farms in Monroe Township, Holmes County, Ohio, revealed that the Anderson Farm and the Bird farm were adjoining properties. That could explain how Guy and Lilis had gotten acquainted. (My Aunt Rhema was one of two children of Guy and Lilis. My mother was one of three children from Guy’s second marriage to Vera Stout.) Guy knew Vera from school in the town of Killbuck, my mother told me. That must have been when they were in elementary grades, because Guy was older than Vera, and there was no high school until she started 9th grade.
Did Lilis die of a broken heart? It seems it was a more prosaic reason. She died just weeks after giving birth to her second child, a not uncommon occurrence at the time.
Guy’s Aunt Caroline Anderson married Leonard Bird, brother of Lilis. 1870
Guy married Lilis Bird in 1898.
Mary Edith Anderson, the daughter of Caroline’s older brother William McCabe Anderson, married Burgess Bird, older brother of Lilis. 1903
SIDE NOTE: Mary Edith and Burgess had a daughter, Imah Bird, certainly one of the more interesting names on my tree!
Caroline’s sister, Amy Anderson (Roof), had been engaged to a Bird, (about 1870) but married another man entirely. Amy raised Rhema, and no doubt was the source of the stories Rhema heard painting Vera Anderson as a temptress who ruined Lilis’ life. Guy and Vera were married in 1904, 13 months after Lilis’ death,
The Allisons
Mother from time to time referred to Allison cousins, and it took me a while to figure out that connection.
John Anderson (My great-great grandfather) was married (About 1820) to Emma Allison in Pennsylvania. They had four children, and after she died, he married my great-great grandmother, Isabel Sarah McCabe and they moved to Ohio.
I don’t know if John’s first wife belonged to the same family that lived near the Anderson’s farm in Holmes County, Ohio, but there were other Anderson/Allison connections in Ohio.
William McCabe Anderson’s son John Edmund Anderson, married Bertha Allison. (about 1894)
And just to keep things interesting, here’s an Anderson- Bird-Allison connection: Lilis Bird Anderson’s father’s first wife (not Lilis’ mother) was an Alison.
And in another knot in this tangled thread, Great-grandmother Mary Brink Anderson’s sister, Ada Brink, married William DeSylva Allison.(1885) Their son Errett and his wife worked for Guy and Vera Anderson on their farm.
The Brinks
Now we come to a family that is actually a direct ancestral connection to me through my mother.
Franklin Anderson, brother of Caroline and Amy and half brother of William McCabe Anderson, married Sarah Jane Brink.(1874)
Frank’s older brother, my great grandfather, Joseph J. Anderson, married Sarah Jane’s sister, Mary Brink, my great grandmother.(1877) (When Joe died early, Mary’s sister Sarah Jane and her husband Frank Anderson took in her two young sons, Guy and Ben. Later, when Guy’s wife Lilis died, Frank and Sarah Jane took in Rhema until Sarah Jane died and Frank’s sister Amy Anderson Roof, by then a widow, moved in to help with Rhema.)
So there you have it. A few cousins untangled.

