Here’s a Map from the book Caldwell’s Atlas of Holmes County (1875). The 1875 map shows Jeddiah and his father Abraham W. Brink’s properties side by side. Killbuck/Oxford town is at top of map, other two arrows point to Middaugh properties. (Enlarge view, using the tools on your internet browser for details).
Jedidah and Abraham W. Brink’s properties outlined in blue. 1875
I have a similar map for one of my ancestors! They are difficult for me to find for my area of research, but certainly worth the effort when I do find them.