Here’s a Map from the book Caldwell’s Atlas of Holmes County (1875). The 1875 map shows Jeddiah and his father Abraham W. Brink’s properties side by side. Killbuck/Oxford town is at top of map, other two arrows point to Middaugh properties. (Enlarge view, using the tools on your internet browser for details).
I have a similar map for one of my ancestors! They are difficult for me to find for my area of research, but certainly worth the effort when I do find them.